Following on from Andrea’s use-wear analyses on Bronze Age axes, a new experiment is now on the go. Josh Desrosier, a Newcastle University student, has been working alongside Andrea to test out a number of replica bronze axes. While it may look like we were having a pleasant day out in the woods chopping down a few trees (which we were!) there were some significant aims to the whole exercise.
An early Bronze Age flat axe, a mid Bronze Age palstave and a late Bronze Age socketed axe were cast and hafted by bronze smith Neil Burridge. These axes were based on British prototypes and then used by Josh and Andrea in a series of controlled field tests that involved felling and sectioning birch trees on National Trust property near Wallington in Northumberland.
The experiments were designed to find out
1) whether changes in the shape and hafting styles of bronze age axes were motivated by increased efficiency
2) whether any of the axes displayed different wear traces during the experiment.
While we’re still waiting for the official results of the tests, some effects became clear immediately. Firstly, a Bronze Age axe in the hands of a fit and healthy individual is a very efficient tool. Josh had some tree felling experience and so knew good techniques, but even so the speed that a tree could be felled and sectioned was impressive. Secondly, we noticed that even after felling four trees, the cutting blade had only blunted slightly- certainly not enough to warrant re-sharpening. But on close inspection of the cutting edge at the end of the day we could see the beginnings of small nicks forming and the tell tale scratch marks that have indicated heavy use on so many of our real Bronze Age axes.
Experimental and reconstructive archaeology is not only a lot of fun, it can help answer long standing questions. And after all, why bother getting involved in endless academic debates when a day out in the woods might yield some answers!
For more info about the experiment, see Josh’s blog:
http://batwep.wordpress.com
Josh starting on a tree
An action shot!
A very clean cut
Taking a cast of the blade. The putty is fine enough to show use wear marks.
You made some good points there. I did a search on the issue and found most people will agree with your blog.
We’re a gaggle of volunteers and starting a brand new scheme in our community. Your web site provided us with valuable information to paintings on. You’ve done an impressive process and our whole group will probably be thankful to you.