Elon Musk fuels further debate on symmetrical comms!

PUT down your PR text books, the validity of Grunig and Hunt’s 2-way symmetrical communication has reared its head again!

This year in preparation for assessments, we have quite spent some time discussing whether excellent PR exists or is just a good idea? In my view, it’s more of an ideal than a reality but then came along billionaire businessman Elon Musk with an intriguing example of 2-way balanced comms.

Earlier this month, the wannabe super-hero and part time rocket man polled his Twitter followers, asking them if he should sell 10% of his Tesla stock. He promised to abide by the result; by a 58-42 margin, his followers said he should sell. 

And he did, selling around £3.7billion of stock a few days after the poll. On the surface, a fairly simple example of an organisation asking stakeholders to advise on policy and abiding by that decision. Elon asked, Elon listened and then Elon acted.

But did he?

Unpack the offer a little and it seems symmetrical Elon is not all it seems. Media reports appear to suggest that Musk had been intending to sell the shares for some time as part of a pre-arranged trading plan agreed in September. However, the amount sold was much higher than had been expected.

So, is Elon’s gesture a genuine example of 2 way symmetrical communication, or merely a publicity stunt engineered to gain attention and favour from social audiences. And there’s more: it appears that the sale comes as US Democrats have proposed a so-called “billionaires tax”, which could see the richest in US society taxed on unrealised gains on stocks they own.

Therefore, is Elon Musk’s request a genuine attempt at prompting a balanced relationship, or is it more about protecting his wealth if and when the tax agencies come knocking? Many commentators have been cynical, suggesting Musk’s gesture is nothing more than a publicity stunt. One stock market expert in New York wrote: “This is not novel. It just gets more attention because it’s such a high market-cap type, attention grabbing kind of company.”

Genuine excellent PR or just a messy publicity stunt with hints of propaganda? It’s hard to tell!

Meanwhile our own PR students have been offering their views on whether 2-way symmetrical comms is ideal or reality.

We set the question on one of our discussion forums and got some great feedback.

Huize was clear that it’s a reality: “When there is a crisis in the digital age, PR can build a platform based on bidirectional symmetry to listen to the different opinions and information of the public because information can be collected on a large scale and quickly.”

But Huize also referred to Pieczka’s view that balanced comms is difficult when there is a power conflict between the ‘elite’ PR practitioner and the publics it communicates with. “In this case, the public will be at a disadvantage under the guidance of PR personnel, intentionally or not, which is a two-way asymmetric communication mode.”

Shuo feels that 2-way symmetrical comms is essential for businesses to thrive in 21st century economic models. “The company needs to make its products better for the public and there is no better way to achieve this goal than listening to its customers.”

Shiqi agreed stating that the emergence of digital and social media platforms made communication a much more level and balanced experience. “Traditional media, like TV, newspapers and radio do not have too many methods to collect feedback and ideas from audiences, the activities they do mostly use publicity and public information models. But in the era of the Internet, things can be done in a much easier way.”

This was also a view suggested by Yueqi who said: “Organizations can now collect people’s opinions through the Internet, social media and official websites and it is also more convenient and cheaper for the public to participate in these activities. People can choose whether to offer opinions and suggestions to the organization, and the organization can choose to accept people’s suggestions or not, and this is how two-way communication works.”

Yasmine took a more cynical view expressing that the name ‘excellence model’ states a lot about its achievability and should be viewed as largely idealistic. However, she posted a note of optimism adding: “I also think that the two-way symmetrical communication model is now more achievable than ever with the growth of social media and online communication between organisations and their publics. For example, Tesla CEO Elon Musk regularly responds and deals with customer complaints and inquiries on Twitter, taking on feedback and suggestions to improve their experiences as Tesla customers.”

Emir was balanced in his response stating that 2-way symmetrical comms was essential for some sectors such as tech and IT where, customer response and feedback is needed to make improvements and adaptations. However, Emir added: “On the other hand, the model is an ideal for say, the corporate sector and politics. While they will never admit it or show it, I think they are still in “publics be damned” stage, and they only deal with the wishes of the public when their profits come into question.”

Meiyu’s considered response stated that social media has improved both the timeliness and scope of organisational comms. However, Maiyu warned that feedback is not comprehensive or representative of the general population. “This may only be the advice of some customers who participated in the interaction, and there may be many customers who did not participate in the interaction, or they do not agree, or elderly people who do not know how to use social software and did not participate in the interaction.”

So, are we any further forward? Is the question of 2-way symmetrical comms still an unsolvable conundrum, or are there genuine glimpses of organisations embedding it as part of the business strategy and values? Only the future will tell is the model is viable or not.

#CreatorAwards22 Are you student blogger of 2022?

“PUBLIC Relations is all about reputation” has been the mantra during our first few weeks of teaching.

But it’s also about communication, content, writing and digital media – all skills that you will learn about and build during your year with us.

And what better way to develop your content writing capabilities than by becoming a PR student blogger?

Every year, PR Academy runs a student blogger competition for everyone enrolled on a PR or comms related course in the UK. This is YOUR opportunity to develop and perfect creative content that will build your personal brand and get you noticed by potential employers.

Traditionally, the #CreatorAwards22 has been dominated by some of our neighbouring universities and colleges, but last year Newcastle students took up the challenge and put themselves proudly on the map.

Among them was Sophie Smith who, while writing for this blog, started to get recognised for her excellent networking and writing skills – including an internship with Stephen Waddington – and is now starting a new role as a Digital PR and Content Executive.

The contest works via the #CreatorAwards22 and #PRStudent hashtags, which picks up any content that PR students have created over the past few days. Then, weekly winners and their universities are announced ahead of an annual ceremony to announce the student PR blogger of the year.

Richard Bailey, editor of PR Academy’s PR Place Insights, said: “We are keen to discover talented content creators from among current UK-based public relations students. We’re looking to identify examples of creative content that support a student’s personal brand and which might appeal to employers.

“This content could be a blog post; it could be a conversation on Twitter; it could be audio or video or photo content. We’ll be sharing a selection of creative content examples each week of the academic year and towards the end of the year we will name a shortlist of creators from which we’ll pick the winners.”

Our students at Newcastle have already made a fantastic start by sharing their experiences of the first week of students by writing a blog post. For example, Jaiqin who told us about becoming a course rep and her desire to volunteer during her studies; Kefan about his love of fish and chips and struggles with the different UK coins; or Sahra who wrote: “I’m in the right place and the right time, and from the deep of my heart I was sure that I made the best decision to start the new chapter of my life with Newcastle University.”

Yumeng wrote a lovely post about our induction week picnic in Leazes Park, which although a breezy day, was a wonderful chance to meet our new students.

Yumeng said: “After the academic session, the tutors organised a picnic in Leazes Park. Many impressions still vivid in my mind, like the lake in the park, the sparkling light of which is also reflected in my heart. Lush trees, waddling geese, police officers patrolled on horseback… We sat on the grass and felt the poetry of nature coming from the wind.”

We have also heard from Huiyun who has been getting to grips with shopping apps and checking out the UK supermarkets; and Qi , who is loving life in the Armstrong Building because it reminds her of Hogwart’s; while Long is learning  to rush around between classes – we feel your pain and that’s why you will soon see some changes to the timetable!

Thanks so much to all of you who submitted blog posts about your first week at Newcastle – we really enjoyed reading them.

But now, it’s over to you – get writing, get blogging and use the hashtag #PRstudent or click the link here to find out more about #CreatorAwards22

The past winners list has one distinct absence – can we change that in 2022? Yes we can!

Back to School!

By Anne-Marie Lacey

Here in the UK, the month of September signals the start of the ‘back to school’ season. My social media feeds are peppered with students packing their bags, leaving home and heading to university for the first time, all the way through to proud parents posting pictures of their little ones dressed in uniform on their very first day of school.

This got me thinking… I’ve been where you are before. Just over a decade ago (after a short break to work in sales and marketing between my undergraduate and post-graduate qualifications), I was nervously packing my bag for my first day at university to study for my Masters Degree in Public Relations with accreditation by the CIPR.

With the benefit of hindsight and thinking about how the PR, communication and media landscape looks today, I thought I’d share with you my top five tips for preparing to go ‘back to school’ ahead of your first workshops, seminars and lectures on your course!

1. Register for a Twitter account

It’s important that you start building your professional network (it’s never too early to start) and Twitter is a great place to do this. If you haven’t already got an account, you can register for one for free.

Remember, it’s important that you’re professional in your approach, so make sure you use a sensible name, @handle, profile picture and biography. You’re not only representing yourself to potential future employers, you’re also representing Newcastle University and this programme of study as a student.

Then, start following media commentators, communication professionals and industry bodies. Here are some suggestions to get you started and from here you can then decide based on the accounts’ content who else you want to follow:

Newcastle University

Media, Culture and Heritage at Newcastle University

The national and regional CIPR account

Stephen Waddington, CIPR President 2013, and Visiting Professor of PR Practice here at Newcastle

2. Engage with Stephen Waddington’s content

As mentioned in #1, Stephen is Visiting Professor of PR Practice here at Newcastle. He also runs a successful PR and communications management consultancy called Wadds Inc, is a published author, curates a community of PR and communications professionals on Facebook and regularly creates super useful content that is easily accessible.

Take the time to explore Stephen Waddington’s website and sign up for his free emails. He publishes a newsletter every Monday morning rounding up the previous week’s media and communication news.

3. Get familiar with your trade media

Subscriptions can be expensive, but lots of different trade media like The Drum, PRMoment, CIPR’s Influence blog and Provoke Media host industry news stories about the latest happenings on their websites. Take the time to check them out, sign up for their regular emails, and keep abreast of the latest industry news.

These publications are a great way to see how people are applying the theory you’re learning in practice, who the movers and shakers are in the industry (and therefore who you may also want to follow on Twitter), as well as news about internships and job opportunities.

4. Keep up-to-date with the UK media too!

Immerse yourself in the UK media on a daily basis. A fun little challenge to do (and in fact this used to be one of my daily jobs when I was a PR Account Executive first starting out in the industry) is to read, watch and listen to the days news stories and try to figure out the source of the story.

Is it breaking news, is it an evolving news story, or has it been generated as a result of Public Relations activity? If you can hone this skill, it’ll help you to develop a good nose to sniff out a news story, understand how the media works, and ultimately what types of stories journalists are interested in which is super important when it comes to media relations.

5. Have the right mind set.

As you’re studying a post-graduate degree, you obviously have previously studied, and so joining Newcastle is very much a case of ‘back to school’ for you. However, please don’t think that your learning will be all wrapped up in a nice degree certificate scroll at the end of this academic year.

No – I did my Master Degree over a decade ago and I can tell you now, the industry today looks very different from what I was taught back then. I’ve no doubt your experience will be the same: 10 years after graduation, while the theories and frameworks you’ll learn over the next year will stand you in good stead, the industry will have progressed at such a pace you’ll have lots of new skills you need to learn, too.

With that in mind, please watch my Introduction to the CIPR Sway as part of your Welcome Week activies, and give serious consideration to joining the Instiute as a Student Member. You’ll have access to a whole host of useful resources that will not only be relevant for your studies here and now, but if you continue your membership journey with the CIPR, the life-long commitment to Continous Professional Development (CPD) will certainly help to set you up for a successful career in PR and communiction.

All that is left for me to say is welcome to Newcastle, good luck with your studies, and I look forward to meeting you all very soon!

PR Under Supervision

Shall I stay in the ‘real world’ or leap into another galaxy? 

By this time of the academic year, most of you will be looking for jobs with some of our students already having cinched their first jobs in the industry – hats off to those rising stars!

While Stephen Waddington’s last MAsterclass gives you plenty of advice on how and where to find employment, this post veers off towards an entirely different career route – doing a PhD in PR. 

Let’s start with basics: why do a PhD?

Right now, you’re in the middle of enduring your research quests, ideas are dropping right and left like heavy rocks during an earthquake, data is snowballing into an avalanche, and you’ve no idea how you’ll ever get to the top of your dissertation Everest. Essentially, you’re running a mountain marathon and I’m asking you to consider doing an ultrarun or maybe a leap into another universe altogether.

A visual representation of writing an MA dissertation struggle. To the left: early stages. To the right: reaching the deadline.

A visual representation of writing an MA dissertation struggle. To the left: early stages. To the right: reaching the deadline.

A PhD, essentially, is a passport to another galaxy of research and knowledge. You all are aware that PR is a relatively new, fast-growing discipline and this means a couple of important things: there is a lot to discover and contribute to the body of knowledge as well as to the industry itself.           

Entire new galaxies of PR knowledge awaiting future PhD students.

“Doing a PhD now allows me to see things from a different perspective,” says Jesus Salazar, our programme alumni and a current PhD student at Newcastle University.

“It lets me be more critical towards the industry and the day-to-day practices, contributing to the field by doing something that is often disregarded in PR: theorising. I can study communication phenomena, developing, testing, and proposing new ideas and strategies.”

In short, PhD not only prepares you to become independent scholars and researchers in higher education. It develops your critical thinking, data analysis and synthesis which enable you to make rational, evidence-based decisions and find solutions – and those, my dear students, are crucial skills for anyone craving a high-level, high-impact career.

Communication technician vs communication manager

While in 2020 CIPR’s State of the Profession Survey showed that copywriting and editing remained the most commonly undertaken activity among practitioners across different levels of seniority, the remaining top nine activities placed emphasis on strategic influence:          

CIPR State of the Profession Report 2020: copywriting and editing is the most common activity undertaken by both senior and junior practitioners.

As you can imagine, the pandemic resulted in unprecedented changes to the industry and client needs. The top priorities shifted to issues management, strategic counsel, and stakeholder management. On an agency level, practitioners highlighted an increased demand for better evaluation and measurement, too. 

CIPR State of the Profession Report 2021: crisis and issues management activities increased by 50%.

In other words, the growing trends represent the need for critical thinking, data gathering, management, and synthesis leading to solutions – the key pillars of any substantial research.

Crisis and critical thinking

Remember, most reputational crises occur due to lack of critical assessment of the situation the organisation is facing.

Think back to the crises you examined in your Strategies and Management in PR assessment – were any of them unavoidable? Of course not, and most of you rightly placed them in Coombs’s intentional crisis cluster since those organisations or individuals took risks; risks that led to negative response from their publics.

Who was responsible for taking those risks? If you remember the VW crisis, the company’s management tried to distance themselves from it by blaming their employees. But we know it’s not the employees who sign off campaigns. Those crises happened because people at the decision-making level, including C-suite executives decided that the actions they’ve taken were a good idea. They lacked the ability to reflect on the impact their actions would have. In short, they lacked critical thinking.

What areas of interest are there to explore?

The world of research is your oyster: you can investigate AI, ethics and global publics, social mobility in PR, international communication in times of global disasters, to name just a few.

The list is endless and for some inspiration you may want to revisit Stephen’s previous MAsterclass on research in PR as well as some interesting ready-to-explore topics listed on his blog.  

In essence, a PhD builds on what you’ve already studied and takes you to another level of expertise, an expertise no one else has.

Alastair Morgan, also our alumni, currently studying at Leeds Beckett University says: “My Master’s degree in Media and Public Relations at Newcastle provided me with the ideal foundations to undertake the PhD for which I am currently studying.

“My area of interest is in political communication and my research will investigate ways in which programmes of democratic engagement may be made more inclusive of young people with special educational needs.”

It means that if you’re into political communication, your research may impact policies. You may end up working for the government on international NGOs. And similarly to Alastair’s inspirations, you may get a chance to change or improve policies – in his case, to make politics more inclusive and accessible to young and disadvantaged people. How does this sound in terms of making an impact?

How to find a PhD?

There are two commonly used approaches:

Subscribe to a PhD search engine, such as www.findaphd.com or https://www.postgraduatesearch.com which usually give you information about funding options for domestic and international students. 

Look directly at university websites in places that interest you – you’ll find more options available, but there’ll be more data to sift through since you’ll be checking one institution at a time. Look at university rankings in your field of interest – the QS World University Rankings by Subject is a good place to start.

Good practice involves networking, too – again, a key skill in PR – through social media and conferences, so you get to know who the experts (read: potential supervisors in the field) are and engage with them even before you submit your proposal.

Typically, universities recruit around November/December for the next academic year, so start your research the moment you submit your dissertation. The good thing is that by now, you all know how to write a proposal!

What’s next?

There are plenty (PLENTY!) of job opportunities in academia across the globe, from London, Hamburg, Singapore, Hong Kong, Santiago, Dubai to Cape Town. 

Academia, however, won’t be the only available career route. Very often, doctorate graduates find themselves working in web publishing, advising governments or international bodies and this is when you can make a difference and influence policies.

Your research interests will have a major impact on where your doctoral degree might take you. But from Jesus’s perspective, the journey itself is an extremely rewarding process:

 “Above all, it has been a journey of self-discovery,” he says. 

“Doing a PhD has helped me find myself, find my voice, my position in this crazy world, and understand who I am.”

Joseph Hiller: Generation (2005)

And this is what I wholeheartedly wish you regardless of your chosen post-MA path.

PR lessons from Euro 2020

NOW that Euro 2020 has come to a disappointing end for all but the Italians, what are the public relations lessons we can learn from the four-week festival of football?

If it came down to contexts, then clear and balanced communication lifts the trophy after a tense penalty shoot-out with dignified leadership. Misplaced brand synergies and political band-wagoning were knocked out in the group stages.

Public relations is all about reputation – what you say, what you do and what others say about you. It’s a mantra that spans a multitude of disciplines and contexts from fashion brands to football, personal life to political life.

So, who were the winners and who were the losers at Euro 2020?

Winner – a leadership culture

England manager Gareth Southgate has deservedly been recognised as a great communicator and a role model for how exemplary culture at the top will filter throughout an organisation or team. As social responsibility guru Peter Drucker says: ‘culture eats strategy for breakfast’.

Southgate’s England are unlike any international squad in my long footballing memory which were largely made up of talented, but often overrated individuals.

Southgate is not just a team selector. For years within his FA roles, he has been nurturing a culture and crop of likeable, positive role models whose values of self-respect, dignity often outshine their footballing talent. These players may be millionaires, but their genuine altruism is far more affecting and effective than that from the leaders we are traditionally expected to aspire to.

Southgate’s leadership can be likened to van Riel’s Elements of Corporate Identity with a clear purposeful culture developed from the top, complimented by what it says and does on and off the pitch. Ultimately, these shared values filter beyond to fans, the media and other stakeholders to create a positive image for the England camp.

Winner – England football team. Not only has the reputation of the team been enhanced on the pitch, the dignified way in which the young lions conducted themselves throughout the tournament was exemplary.

As footballers, the players are part of the production sub-system – providing the services to help achieve organisational goals. But the manner in which they responded to the despicable racist abuse following the final defeat, demonstrated that they were part of an adaptive system, too, responding and adjusting to external threats with dignity and clarity. Let’s not forget, several of these players are still very young.

There were examples of symmetrical communication within the team’s social media responses too with Tyrone Mings’ powerful tweet calling out the UK government’s hypocrisy triggering a heated Parliamentary exchange and stimulating debate over the ethics and declining values of political leadership.

Winner – a crisis managed with Danish dignity

It seems an age ago now, but the first Saturday of the tournament brought one of the most upsetting moments ever seen in sport when the Danish captain and talisman Christian Eriksen collapsed on the pitch after suffering cardiac arrest. For around 30 minutes, medics attempted to revive Eriksen while team-mates formed a dignified barrier around the player and comforted his wife who was watching at the pitch-side.

For several days, the tournament appeared in doubt as players, fans and commentators correctly opined that football is and never has been more important than life or death. Eriksen’s recovery inspired and unified the Danish team and nation to the semi-final of the tournament.

But the real winner from this traumatic event was increased public awareness and attitudes towards life-saving CPR training and skills. Eriksen’s collapse triggered international media interest in cardiac conditions, particularly when impacting seemingly young and fit people. This has spurred investment in life-saving defibrillators and new processes to ensure communities know where their nearest defibrillator is.

Loser – brand synergies shown the red card

Very early in Euro 2020, superstar Cristiano Ronaldo made his disdain for corporate sponsors Coca-Cola clear by moving aside two strategically placed Coke bottles during a press conference. A few days later, France’s Paul Pogba did likewise with bottles of Heineken during a media briefing.

Sponsorship is an essential part of corporate sport and international tournaments would disappear without it. But global audiences are not the passive consumers they once were; social media means publics have a strong voice and will actively call out mis-matching between brand and tournament leading to huge reputational risk for the mega brands. Ronaldo didn’t get to be the world’s greatest footballer by guzzling Cokes and Pogba doesn’t kick back with a beer after the match. So, don’t make that insinuation that they do – it’s disingenuous, misleading and damaging to the brand as was shown when an estimated $4billion was wiped off Coca Cola’s share value after Ronaldo’s actions.

Far better to take a subtler approach, identifying synergies between tournament and brand or to develop audiences and awareness in emerging regions. Chinese brands Hisense and AliPay were all over Euro 2020’s pitch-side advertising hoardings supporting their global strategy for recognition within sports markets – a clever move which will have brought these names to prominence in Europe and enhanced their reputation in Asia.

Wooden spoon – Own goal calamities and political gesturing

Prime Minister Boris Johnson has a long history of saying or doing the wrong thing at the wrong time – after all, it’s how he got to be the leader of the country. But his insincere band-wagoning during the Euro semi-final at Wembley demonstrated once again how out of touch political leaders can be.

The hastily arranged ‘Boris 10’ England shirt pulled snugly over an already dishevelled figure was a desperate publicity stunt which reeked of opportunism of the lowest kind. Let’s not forget this is the same Boris Johnson who has previously declared little interest in football and refused to condemn those who booed England players taking the knee.

Yet just yards away, young Prince George demonstrated his enthusiasm by belting out the national anthem and cheering on the team to victory – and he didn’t have to pull on a mini England shirt to show his genuine passion.

Elsewhere amongst the political elite were examples of ministers and MPs trashing the knee-taking as political gesturing then weeks later lining up to condemn the racists. Both literally and metaphorically, PM Johnson clearly believes he can have his cake AND eat it and needs to be relegated to the subs bench soon.

All in all, Euro 2020 was a successful tournament for football, particularly for beleaguered fans starved of the thrill of an international spectacle. But again, the tournament served as a valuable reminder that reputation is earned and public scrutiny means that what is said, what is done and what others say needs to more in balance than ever before.

Images courtesy of You Tube, UEFA, independent.co,uk, talksport.com, indy100.com

Award-winning theory!

Did you know you’re taught the same models and frameworks PR practitioners use to enter (and win!) industry awards?

Over the past 14 months, the world and life as we once knew it has drastically changed due to the pandemic. In both our personal and professional lives, we can all name at least a handful of special events that were cancelled, moved to being exclusively online, or had their format altered to account for social distancing and keep delegates and other attendees safe.

The PR industry was not exempt from these changes, with many highlights of the calendar being cancelled, including the Chartered Institute of Public RelationsPRide Awards.

Anne-Marie with Colin Jackson, a former BBC Look North presenter, at CIPR North-East PRide Awards 2018.

Historically, June marks the start of the awards season in the PR event’s calendar, with some of the industry’s biggest and brightest talents – from freelancers and independent practitioners, to agencies, consultancies and in-house teams both large and small – coming together at a glittering black-tie evening event to celebrate the achievements of the past year.

Each year, from international celebrations to national and even on a smaller regional level, many PR practitioners and teams up and down the country look forward to coming together to mark their achievements over the past 365 days.

Last year, however, the CIPR took the difficult decision to cancel all of its PRide Awards across the country due to the pandemic. The good news is that the Pride Awards are  making a return (albeit in a different Covid-secure format) in 2021!

A statement on the CIPR website reads:

The CIPR PRide Awards are back for 2021 to recognise the outstanding work you’ve been delivering across the UK in the last 24 months. We’re shining the spotlight on the best PR teams and campaigns in nine of the UK’s regions, helping you increase your visibility, impress clients and attract new business.  Give your team the boost they need after a year like no other and enter the CIPR PRide Awards by 29 June. We’ll celebrate your achievements at our virtual free-to-attend award ceremonies later this year.

Sounds pretty impressive, right? So, what does it take to win one of these awards?

Well, I am in the very lucky position to have been on both sides of the fence. During my career of working in PR, not only have I won awards for my work on a regional and national level (and on a personal level too – I was once named the CIPR’s Young Communicator of the Year at both the PRide and Excellence Awards), I’ve also had the pleasure of judging these awards too. Not to mention, when the CIPR rolled out a brand-new category for Influencer Marketing, I was one of two working PR professionals who actually wrote the entry requirements and marking criteria, and now I can share with you what it takes to be a winner.

Essentially, it comes down to being able to clearly communicate what your campaign was all about: what research you did and how this informed your strategy, your objectives and the tactics you used, and what results you achieved.

Sound familiar? It should do! Basically, real-life working PR practitioners are using the same planning frameworks that you’re taught at Newcastle University both in their day-to-day work, but also in writing award-winning entries that will “help increase visibility, impress clients and attract new business” – a very interesting proposition in a competitive marketplace!

What do these frameworks look like? It’s SOSTAC! So, if you want to pass some of your PR planning assignments as well as potentially winning some awards once you enter the world of work, remember Situation, Objectives, Strategy, Tactics, Actions and Control.

Situation:

What is the environment your campaign is taking place in? Do your research to find out what’s happening both internally and externally to your organisation. Don’t forget your PESTLE and to plot a SWOT analysis.

Objectives:

Now that you know what is happening in and around your organisation at the time of planning your campaign, what is it you want to achieve through your PR and communications? Make your objectives SMART – specific, measureable, achievable, realistic and timely.

Remember, if you can’t think how you’ll measure and evaluate your objective at the beginning of your campaign, don’t write it down as an objective. Also think about how your SMART communication objectives help to support wider corporate objectives for your campaign to be really meaningful.

Strategy:

What’s the big idea for your campaign? Can you create audience personas – who are you trying to communicate with? Who are your key publics, how important are they, and how much time or effort do you need to give to engaging with them – remember Johnson and Scholes Stakeholder Mapping?

Then develop your messaging and tone of voice that will resonate with your audience. Don’t forget AIDA and DRIP (Awareness, Interest, Desire, Action and Differentiate, Remind/Reassure, Inform, Persuade respectively). Think YSIC (Why Should I Care?), WIIFM (What’s In It For Me) and KFD (Know Feel Do).

What is it you want your audience to think, feel or do as a result of your campaign? Remember, the most successful PR campaigns are about awareness and behavioural change – not just editorial coverage or social media reach.

Tactics:

This is where your 3 E’s and a Pub within the PESO setting comes into play. Don’t forget to think about editorial, electronic, events, publications and mixed media, across the spectrum of paid, earned, shared and owned media.

Remember, when creating content and channel planning, always have your audience and objectives in mind. Will your communications reach the right audience, will they be able to decode and understand your message, will they engage with the content and ultimately help you to achieve your objectives?

Action:

You now know what you want to do and how you’re going to do it, but when it comes to rolling out your campaign, you need a plan of action. What needs to happen and when, who is in charge of that element of your campaign and how much will it cost. Remember, when we’re talking about cost, it’s important to think about the 3M’s – money, manpower and machines.

It’s not just about the pounds (or any other currency) when it comes to cost; consider the capacity of your team and how much time they’ll need to spend on completing their actions, as well as the cost of any equipment, machinery or other bought-in services that need to be accounted for to help bring your campaign to life. Once you have this information, plot it all onto a GANNT chart working backwards from your campaign launch date (or D-Day) to make sure your activity is mapped out by ownership, responsibility, time and cost.

Control:

Finally, think about how you will measure and evaluate the success of your PR campaign. Using your SMART objectives, have you achieved what you set out to do? If not, can you perform a gap analysis? If you haven’t achieved your objectives, how far away were you from hitting your KPIs and can you explain why this didn’t happen, or even identify learnings for the future from this analysis exercise?

Remember, there’s so much more to measurement and evaluation than just the number of pieces of media coverage achieved or likes to a social media profile. Look at The Barcelona Principles and AMEC’s integrated framework. Think on a bigger picture and give consideration to how your inputs, outputs, outtakes and outcomes will deliver organisational impact.

And finally, here’s a ‘fun’ fact for you: when judging the CIPR’s awards, any entry that uses the archaic AVEs as a measurement metric, are automatically awarded a score of zero in the measurement and evaluation section. But by now, you all know that AVEs is a worthless metric in PR.  

Stay connected and curious

After over a year of social distancing, having a strong network of social and professional contacts has never been more important: it helped us battle with isolation, but also served as an important avenue for inspiration. Read on to find out how to develop valuable relationships and why it matters for both your summer semester and your future career.

Source: Newcastle University

Networking: a two-way communication model in practice

The core purpose of networking is focused on information exchange, gaining understanding, and creating long-term relationships that are mutually beneficial.

For PR practitioners, whether they engage in lobbying, media relations, international or community relations, having strong networking channels is essential to achieve their goals. For PR students gearing up for their dissertations, networking is of paramount importance when it comes to primary data collection, particularly when your methodology choice calls for qualitative interviews.

But remember, networking is based on two-way exchange based on reciprocity. In other words, and as social theory of exchange proposes, people keep score and any interaction, particularly in the business world, must be balanced out by an exchange of social rewards.

For example, you approach a PR expert for an interview. They give you information while you display respect and acknowledge their contribution formally in your work. If you’re both satisfied with this exchange of rewards, the relationship might continue and develop, offering more opportunities for rewards exchange in the future.

In semester 3, there’ll be a session dedicated to the process of approaching experts for interviews. For now, let’s see which networking channels will be useful both for your research project and the future careers.

Where to find them? Look up their networking channels

There are numerous international bodies gathering PR big wigs whom you can meet both online and offline:

Global Alliance – a PR association gathering over 300,000 practitioners and academics from around the world to unify and promote the standards of the profession globally and you already know the former Chair of Global Alliance – Prof. Anne Gregory. Find them on Facebook, Twitter and LinkedIn and join the conversation.

Many of their sessions are streamed by other associations, for example, last month’s discussion about “Digital Transformation and The Jobs of The Future” was streamed by ASEAN PR YouTube Network.

ASEAN Public Relations Network (APRN) – a member of Global Alliance, APRN’s mission is “to bridge the gap of Public Relations professionals’ competencies in the ASEAN region:” Brunei, Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, Myanmar, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, and Vietnam. Brunei and Singapore are among the top five wealthiest countries in the world while Vietnam was one of the few that recorded a GDP growth in 2020 and, in the pre-pandemic times, its government opened a tourism office in London with the aim of attracting British visitors – something to think about.

You’ll all be familiar with the CIPR, the only PR organisation in the world that administers Chartered Assessment – that is, an award of formal credential in recognition of their highest standards or professional practice. Many international PR associations draw on training and knowledge promoted by the CIPR and there are two key online channels that are a great avenue of connecting with like-minded individuals: CIPR’s main Twitter account and CIPR International. Recently, the latter was promoting a webinar about Tik Tok and generation Z – why not join the conversation and offer views from your perspective?

Once restrictions get lifted, every local branch of the CIPR – including CIPR North East – will be hosting networking events: what’s a better way of meeting people from the area of your interest?

Among several other bodies in the UK, it’s worth pursuing contacts within the Public Relations Communications Association (PRCA). Historically, it was established as a trade association for larger consultancies, but currently both CIPR and PRCA are considered as very similar and there’s nothing to stop you from expanding your network across both organisations!

China International Public Relations Association (CIPRA) is mainly focussed on the development of PR research and practice as well as establishing the industry’s professional standards. Recently, CIPRA held the 8th China University Student Public Relations Planning and Entrepreneurship Competition – check who the speakers and judges were as those contacts will definitely be useful to connect with.

There are many (MANY) international, national, and regional PR associations – way too many to include in this blog entry. The International PR Association, however, compiled a list of 90 organisations from across the globe – all at your fingertips.

Other PR pros habitats

Most agencies and publications have established some sort of an online community – see PRovoke, PR Daily or Spin Sucks or PRWeek to name just a few, and follow the authors of posts across social media platforms. After a while, you’ll start recognising their names (e.g. Ella Minty – make sure you check out her weekly #PowerAndInfluence discussions on Twitter; Richard Bailey or Scott Guthrie) at international events and in specialist coverage and other publications concerning PR.  

Last but not least, Stephen Waddington’s Lockdown: a marketing, media and PR community of practice is a lively and friendly group that gathers 1.8K top industry experts, partitioners, academics and students who engage in an ongoing discussion about communication. “Please pull up a chair and join the conversation,” their Facebook page says.

Why network?

Networking, aside from having a potential to lead to more business or employment, can be an invaluable source of inspiration and aspiration. Exchanging ideas with likeminded people, will help you figure out and reassess what you really know and what your areas of development might be. Even a single conversation can inspire you to follow an area of specialism that will unleash your creative talent.

Taking part in events and voicing your thoughts, whether in an online or offline environment, will also make you quickly stand out and can help you foster your career path. This is a simple equation: the more people you know, they more people you know! And the more high-profile individuals you connect with, the more support you may receive for your future development. With time, this will lead to you becoming a high-status person with powerful connections. Think about your self-confidence at this stage!

Start SMART-ly and always show interest

Networking can seem daunting at first, but you can overcome the initial stage fright by making a plan and starting with small steps. For example, you may decide on reading one blog entry a week and commenting it on the author’s platform. Or you can choose to attend one event a month and introduce yourself to the organisers – all you need to do is thank them for hosting it at first; make sure you’re prepared to introduce yourself in a few sentences.

Whatever your main goal for networking is – whether it’s learning, seeking mentorship, career opportunities or just meeting like-minded people – always remain polite and show interest. Most of PR professionals are incredibly kind and generous with their time, but no one likes being taken for granted. Keep your two-way symmetrical communicators hat on and watch your network expand.

What is toad worship? Playful digital political engagement in China

Toad worship is the new sexy in China. Of course, the ‘toad’ here has nothing to do with the actual animal. It is a subtextual reference that Chinese Internet users invented to describe the former Chinese Communist Party (CCP) leader – Jiang Zemin, who was the most powerful man in the country between 1989 and 2002, because of the big ‘toad’ glasses he often wears.

Meme based on Jiang’s remarks during his visit to the China Union Engineering Corporation

Retired from politics two decades ago and kept a low profile since then, Jiang was suddenly placed under the spotlight again on the Chinese-language Internet in 2016. This year, Jiang turned 90. To celebrate his birthday, millions of Chinese Internet users invented a series of ‘toad worship’ rituals on social media, typically including creating and posting funny memes of Jiang, citing his famous quotations, and sending best wishes to him. According to toad worshipers, “every meme posted […] would extend [Jiang’s] life for one second, and that would make him immortal” (Fang, 2020, p. 38). Despite the government’s heavy censorship, toad worship went viral, becoming one of the most trending digital cultural phenomena on the Chinese-language Internet in the past few years.

Of course, you cannot take the ‘worship’ part of toad worship too seriously. Probably not a single Internet user would believe that their sharing of Jiang’s memes could really extend his life. Instead, their engagement with such rituals more reflects a playful way of political participation developed in a politically restrictive Chinese digital environment.

Based on a textual analysis of 100 toad worship-related memes, as well as interviews with 6 creators and 18 frequent sharers of them, Dr Fang Kecheng – an assistant professor at the Chinese University of Hong Kong discovered that the toad worship culture is both political and apolitical.

On the one hand, Jiang’s era has witnessed the most rapid economic development in China’s modern history, with political restrictions being often perceived to be relatively looser back then. As such, Chinese people’s toad worship involves an implicit criticism of the current CCP leadership, despite the sarcasm encoded in the memes showing that toad worshipers do not completely agree with Jiang’s governance either.

On the other hand, playfulness is also an important apolitical incentive that encourages Chinese Internet users to share funny memes that mock Jiang. In this process, being able to decode these subtextual meanings embedded in the memes also constitute a form of cultural capital, which allows Internet users to show their political literacy within a shared Chinese digital community.

Dr Fang’s research is enlightening, offering us a narrative of Chinese digital culture that is much more dynamic than the regime-vs-people discourse popular with outside observers. If you were interested in toad worship, please go ahead and read Dr Fang’s interesting piece via this link.

References

Fang, K. (2020). Turning a communist party leader into an Internet meme: The political and apolitical aspects of China’s toad worship culture. Information Communication & Society, 23(1), 38–58. https://doi.org/10.1080/1369118X.2018.1485722

Hello from Anne-Marie

Hello everyone!

My name is Anne-Marie and I’m delighted to be writing this blog post as the newest member of the PR and media comms teaching team at Newcastle University.  Before the new term starts and I get to meet you all in person (albeit online via Zoom while social distancing restrictions are still in place), I thought I’d take a few moments to introduce myself, so you can find out a little more about me. Here goes…

What’s the backstory?

Before graduating from university with a Master of Arts in Public Relations accredited by the CIPR, I found my first job in the industry through my student blog, Raising the Profile.  Since then, I quickly moved through the ranks of agency life going from a junior to PR Manager to heading up the Communications and Content division of an integrated brand consultancy, before launching my own business, Filament PR.

Through Filament PR, I’ve worked with clients across the UK and beyond, using data to enlighten strategies and bring bright ideas to life, all while delivering communications campaigns with creative spark. I’ve shone a light on my clients’ position in their marketplace and helped to amplify their messages above and beyond the competition, so they could engage the right people, at the right time and in the right way, helping to achieve business objectives with measureable results.

With over 10 years’ on-the-job experience, I have worked with clients on both B2B and B2C campaigns, from small start-ups to international household brands, winning many awards including ‘gold’ at both the CIPR North East and North West PRide Awards. In 2014, I also won the prestigious title of ‘Outstanding Young Communicator’ at the CIPR North East PRide Awards. Most recently, I won the accolade nationally at the CIPR’s Excellence Awards in June 2017.

My work has always taken an integrated approach to PR and communication using the PESO model, with all campaigns having clear SMART objectives at the start, and robust measuring and monitoring metrics at the end, using AMEC’s framework to demonstrate outputs, out takes and organisational outcomes. These are just some of the things about working in PR and communication that I’m really looking forward to sharing with you.

So, you’ve worked in PR. Well, what about teaching?

As well a running Filament PR, I’ve provided consultancy and coaching services to my clients, helping to upskill their in-house teams to be better communicators.  I have a real passion for sharing my knowledge, and so as well as coaching my clients’ comms teams, I have also taught on PR degrees at the University of Sunderland and Newcastle University accredited by the CIPR, in addition to being a dissertation tutor, working successfully with both home and international students. In fact, pre-pandemic, some of you may have seen me around on campus before!

As well as supporting students and new entrants into the PR industry at regional universities, I’ve worked with communications professionals at different stages of their careers to help develop their skills through the North East Sales & Marketing Academy (nesma), where I’ve delivered CIPR and CIM Qualifications at both undergraduate and post-graduate level, as well as bespoke training on Influencer Marketing.

I hope throughout our time together at Newcastle University you’ll find I have the right combination of teaching experience and practical skills gained from working in PR to provide you with an excellent learning experience – I love it when I can pair real life examples from my own experience underpinned by academic theory, putting classroom learnings into professional practice.

Plus, having completed my own Higher Education studies a decade ago (did you know, one of my lecturers while I was at university was actually Newcastle’s very own Laurel Hetherington? Yes – she’s taught me too!), I’m in a unique position where I am not too far removed from what you are experiencing today – exam stress, assignment deadlines, job hunting, networking and building your own personal brand and profile. I can relate to you and empathise with you, drawing on my experience to support you and help to nurture you – the PR professionals of tomorrow. It’s a super exciting time to be entering the working world of PR post-pandemic. More on that to come in a future blog post, I’m sure…

What about industry connections? Don’t you volunteer with the CIPR too?

Away from the office and classroom environment, I’m a Fellow of the CIPR, Co-Chair of the CIPR’s Influencer Marketing Panel and the immediate past Chair of the North East regional group. I complete annual CPD appraisals to retain my Chartered Practitioner status as well coaching and mentoring other CIPR members. In fact, I was one of the first CIPR members to #GetChartered in the North East and the youngest CIPR Member nationally to be made a Fellow of the Institute.  I am also an Affiliate Professional of the CIM.

Committed to best practice and advancing the profession through marrying academic theory and real-life implementation so that you get the best student experience and graduate from your course being workplace-ready, I have co-researched, written and published a series of three Influencer Marketing Skills Guides for the CIPR, contributed a Practitioner’s Diary to the new Tench and Waddington text book – Exploring Public Relations and Management Communication (5th Ed), and regularly speak at national industry and vertical sector events on PR and communications.

What do you do when you’re not working?

Good question! My home life is pretty busy at the moment. My husband and I welcomed our first child in November last year (a lockdown baby!) – a little boy called Lucas. So, when I’m not working, teaching or volunteering with the CIPR, you can normally find me changing nappies, singing nursery rhymes, reading story books in a funny voice or enjoying nice long walks while pushing the pram.

I’m also a huge Disney fan – I love a good story and think the way the franchise does it is just so magical. Who doesn’t love a happy ending, right? Maybe that’s why I love working in and teaching PR – it’s all about the art and science of storytelling to share messages, create awareness, change behaviours and effect a positive mutual understanding. As soon as the pandemic is over and international travel is allowed, I’m looking forward to taking Lucas on his first trip to meet Mickey Mouse!

Media Relations: The Good, The Bad, and The Unexpected

By Ramona Slusarczyk

Media relations can be exciting and rewarding, but even for the most seasoned PR practitioners and journalists there are times when the unexpected strikes and you need to react fast. 

Join Barbara Henderson, Hannah McMahon, and Ramona Slusarczyk (DPDs for Journalism, International Multimedia Journalism, and Media & PR) as they share some of the most surprising, scary or silly moments from their careers in media and PR.

If you want to know what happens on the ground for PR practitioners and journalists – or you enjoy a good anecdote – this talk is for you. 

Here is the link to the recording https://ncl.instructure.com/files/3891312/download?download_frd=1